Private Forest Accord

Oregonians want healthy forests. We all want good salmon runs. We all want economic stability. We all want more common ground.

Heated disagreements involving forest management are not new to Oregon. Neither are shared values, creative problem-solving and the spirit of compromise. In early 2020, Gov. Kate Brown announced that representatives from the forest and wood products sector and representatives from environmental and fisheries communities had been in discussion, and agreed to try a new path forward in determining the future of many of Oregon’s private forest practices.

Later that year, the Oregon Legislature passed a bill (SB 1602) jointly recommended by representatives of the timber industry and the conservation community that made some immediate changes to the Oregon Forest Practices Act, related to stream buffers and helicopter pesticide application and notification

At the same time, the bill memorialized a series of moderated discussions among the opposing groups, called the Private Forest Accord. The legislation laid the foundation for a mediated process that would foster constructive discussion and review available science related to the impacts of contemporary forest practices on fish and wildlife habitat. Their goal was to determine the best ways to mitigate negative impacts of logging on streams and fish, while establishing regulatory certainty for forest management.

Representatives agreed to meet regularly and earnestly for the better part of a year. They talked. They expressed their concerns and their representative goals. They honored opposing viewpoints and listened. They reviewed science, they called in experts and they determined key goals that should allow Oregon to receive federal approval for a Habitat Conservation Plan on private forestlands.

A habitat conservation plan and accompanying incidental take permit on private forestlands would offer assurances of protected habitat for fish and other aquatic species, and provide future regulatory stability for Oregon’s forest sector.

In October 2021, timber and environmental representatives signed the Private Forest Accord agreement.

Adult coho salmon underwater
Expanded stream buffers are intended to improve habitat for Coho salmon and other aquatic species.

 

TIMELINE

2010-2020
Legislative battles over Oregon’s forest practices regulations on private forestlands were getting more expensive and more divisive. Competing ballot initiatives from the forest industry and conservation communities were prepared for the 2020 Oregon legislative session.

Feb 10, 2020
Governor Brown announces a memorandum of understanding (MOU) between representatives from the state’s forest sector and major environmental and fisheries groups.

The MOU signified a willingness to collaborate toward meaningful, science-based forest management on Oregon’s private forests. It was a show of good faith on both sides.

The parties that signed the MOU agreed to withdraw all forestry-related initiative petitions and related litigation. In addition, the signed MOU did three things – it:

  1. Supported legislation for the Oregon Legislature’s 2020 session to immediately change the Oregon Forest Practices Act related to modifying the E-Notification system to improve communications for helicopter pesticide spray and increasing the no-spray buffers around homes, schools and drinking water intakes. 
  2. Expanded the width of stream buffers along Salmon, Steelhead and Bull trout (SSBT) streams in Oregon’s Rogue-Siskiyou region. 
  3. Signified a willingness from both sides to collaborate toward meaningful, science-based forest management changes on Oregon’s private forests. These changes will be the basis for developing a Habitat Conservation Plan for fish and riparian species on private forestlands. The state will seek endorsement of the plan from federal wildlife agencies to ensure that Oregon’s private forest practice regulations are protective of threatened and endangered species.
     

June 26, 2020
The Oregon Legislature passed Senate Bill 1602, nearly unanimously.

  • The legislation was proposed by the groups represented in the original MOU. It included: 
  • new regulations for helicopter spraying of pesticides
  • modifying the electronic notification system to become a neighbor reporting system for helicopter herbicide application
  • expanded buffers of unharvested trees required along salmon, steelhead and bull trout (SSBT) streams in the Rogue-Siskiyou region

The legislation also established the Private Forest Accord (PFA). This is an agreement between forest sector and environmental representatives, along with the office of Gov. Kate Brown. The PFA is not a set of recommended laws, but instead a series of mediated meetings held between members of this diverse group of forestry and environmental stakeholders, and eventual subcommittee efforts to develop proposed changes to the regulations governing Oregon’s private forests and forest practices.

SB 1602 also helped establish the funding for coordinating and moderating the accord discussions, and established parameters and guidance for the coming mediation.

Jan 12, 2021
Private, mediated discussions began. Timber interests and environmental groups each designated six representatives to participate in the PFA discussions. Their task was to discuss goals and evidence as well as proposed changes to the Oregon Forest Practices Act, and decide how to move toward securing a statewide Habitat Conservation Plan.

Peter Koehler was appointed mediator of the negotiations, assisted by Peter Harkema.

October 30, 2021
An agreement was reached in the Private Forest Accord.

Ten documents were prepared to provide summaries of the issues covered in the agreement.

The parties agreed on a framework for:

  • expanded riparian buffers, where trees must be left unharvested along streams, rivers and bodies of water
  • modeling and adjusting timber harvest on steep, unstable slopes to protect and enhance stream habitat
  • an approach moving forward to improve forest roads that will limit sediment to water, and aid in fish passage 
  • a path forward using an adaptive management program that would provide science-based recommendations to the Oregon Board of Forestry to adapt and change forest practices regulations in the future based on new scientific findings

The agreement also proposed creating:

  • a small woodland owner tax credit program 
  • a process for monitoring compliance of the new forest practice rules

Language agreed to by the PFA participants was submitted for consideration to the 2022 Oregon Legislature, to solidify the PFA’s suggested changes into statute.

Feb. 2022
PFA participants presented a detailed Private Forest Accord Report to the Legislature, along with draft legislative concepts.

Oregon Legislature considered Senate Bills 1501 and 1502, and House Bill 4055.

Senate Bill 1501
Directs the State Board of Forestry to adopt updates to the Oregon Forest Practices Act.
Key sections:

  • Stream buffers: Updated stream buffers are 10% to 100% larger than currently required under Oregon law, depending on the stream type and its location. Includes new protections for non-fish-bearing streams.
  • Protections of aquatic habitat: Expanded riparian buffers to protect a variety of species that depend on aquatic habitat, including salmon, steelhead, bull trout and amphibians.
  • Forest roads: New standards for road design, inventory, maintenance, management and culvert design. 
  • Unstable slopes: Retains trees in key areas to help protect and enhance streams and other aquatic habitat.
  • Beaver activity: Includes more reporting requirements to the Oregon Department of Fish & Wildlife for managing beaver activity and resolving any nuisances beavers cause to forest landowners.
  • Compliance monitoring: Expands monitoring programs to evaluate whether the new rules are implemented as intended.
  • Mitigation costs: Requires state and private investment in mitigating otherwise unavoidable impacts of compliant logging practices.
  • Adaptive Management Program: Creates a new stakeholder committee that will work with an Independent Research and Science Team to advise the Oregon Board of Forestry on future rule changes to ensure the goals of the Habitat Conservation Plan are met.

Senate Bill 1502
Creates a tax credit program to compensate small forest landowners (those who own less than 5,000 acres and harvest less than 2 million board feet of timber a year) who agree to exclude harvest within the proposed expanded stream buffer zone for the next 50 years. The individual tax credit will be based on estimated lost timber harvest.

House Bill 4055
Establishes future funding under the Forest Products Harvest Tax. Upon approval of a Habitat Conservation Plan, funds would be collected for an Oregon Conservation and Recreation Fund and be available for funding mitigation.   

Senate Bills 1501 and 1502 and House Bill 4055 passed. Now the Oregon Board of Forestry is tasked with integrating the regulations outlined in the bills into the Oregon Forest Practices Act, and establish new forest practice rules for private forest landowners under the Act. 

A new culvert improves fish passage

 

WHAT'S NEXT?

The next long-term process will be developing and pursuing a statewide Habitat Conservation Plan for private forestlands in Oregon. The Oregon Board of Forestry will oversee the plan, and then present it to federal fish and wildlife agencies for approval under the Endangered Species Act.

Most of the rules and programs developed as a result of the PFA and legislative action roll out in 2023-24. Additional rules will be developed in the coming years. A Habitat Conservation Plan is targeted to be completed by the end of 2027.